Self-proclaimed Prophet Shepherd Bushiri and his wife Mary Bushiri have won their long-running extradition battle against the South African government after the High Court of Malawi set aside an earlier order that had directed their surrender to South Africa to face criminal charges.
The High Court overturned the 12 March 2025 decision of the Lilongwe Magistrates’ Court, which had ruled that the couple should be extradited to stand trial for alleged fraud, money laundering, and other offences.
In their review application, the Bushiris argued that the lower court’s proceedings were procedurally unfair and that they had been denied the right to be heard. The High Court agreed, finding that the magistrate failed to balance the couple’s rights and the state’s interests, and described the hearing as “one-sided.”
South African Government Responds
South Africa’s Department of Justice had previously welcomed the March ruling ordering extradition, calling it a “victory for accountability” and a step toward ensuring that “no one is above the law.” Following Friday’s reversal, the department said it would review the judgment and consult with Malawian authorities on possible next steps.
Justice Minister Ronald Lamola has consistently maintained that the Bushiris must return to South Africa to face justice, accusing the couple of using legal maneuvers to delay proceedings.
Bushiris Declare Victory
Speaking through their legal representatives, the Bushiris expressed gratitude to the Malawian judiciary, calling the ruling a vindication of their claim that they would not receive a fair trial in South Africa.
Prophet Bushiri, leader of the Enlightened Christian Gathering (ECG) Church, reiterated that he fled South Africa in 2020 “for safety and justice,” insisting that he was being persecuted, not prosecuted.
Legal and Diplomatic Implications
Legal experts say the decision could further strain diplomatic ties between Malawi and South Africa. Under Malawi’s Extradition Act (Cap 8:03), South Africa may now have to submit a fresh extradition request that addresses the procedural concerns identified by the High Court.
Analysts warn that the ruling could delay or derail South Africa’s efforts to bring the couple back, depending on whether Malawian authorities pursue a new hearing.
What Happens Next
With the High Court judgment now in effect, the extradition order is nullified. The South African government is expected to engage through diplomatic channels to explore legal options for appeal or resubmission of the case.
Meanwhile, the Bushiris remain free in Malawi, where they continue to lead their church and maintain significant public support.