March and March lawyer Xolani Zuma says South Africa should withdraw from the United Nations Refugee Convention for at least two years to “fix its house”, arguing that the current system cannot cope with the number of people it is expected to process, detain and monitor.
Zuma was speaking to journalists during an inspection in loco of the Lindela Repatriation Centre in Krugersdorp by the Johannesburg High Court. Deputy Judge President Aubrey Ledwaba led the delegation, which comprised three judges.
The inspection forms part of a legal challenge in which pro-migrant non-governmental organisations (NGOs) are seeking an order preventing the Department of Home Affairs from detaining undocumented foreign nationals beyond the legally prescribed 120-day period, including those who have applied for asylum.
The NGOs argue that detention beyond 120 days is unlawful and violates the rights of asylum seekers, who should not be detained indefinitely while their applications are being processed.
Home Affairs and those opposing the application argue that the 120-day limit creates challenges for immigration enforcement. They maintain that once individuals are released, authorities often struggle to trace them, making it difficult to complete deportation processes.
“There is a solution to this problem. Withdraw from the convention for at least two years. Fix your house. Put your systems in order. Then you know that you have a proper system, and that is when you can decide how many refugees you can take as a country,” Zuma said.
He argued that South Africa could not continue accepting “thousands and millions” of people without taking the country’s available resources into consideration.
“You can’t take thousands and millions, looking at the resources that you have. How many people are paying tax in the country? Below eight million. How many people are sitting at home unemployed? So those are issues that government must look into,” Zuma said.
Zuma said he believed the matter was now before the courts and expressed confidence that the government would take the concerns seriously.
“I think we are quite happy,” he said.
During a longer interview on the sidelines of the inspection, Zuma emphasised that those detained at Lindela were “our African brothers and sisters”. He said he was satisfied that the living conditions at the centre were “not that bad” and that detainees’ dignity was being respected.
However, he maintained that anyone wishing to come to South Africa must respect the country’s immigration laws and enter through legal channels.
Zuma also highlighted two practical challenges raised during the inspection: a lack of resources within the Department of Home Affairs and insufficient cooperation from foreign embassies in verifying the nationalities of detainees and issuing the travel documents required for deportation.
He said the government needed to engage with its counterparts in other countries to address these challenges.
Zuma further argued that when individuals are released after reaching the 120-day detention limit, authorities often struggle to trace them.
“When you release these people, where do they go? You can’t track them down after that,” he said.
He claimed that some individuals had entered South Africa as asylum seekers decades ago but had still not completed the process of obtaining refugee status. He also alleged that Home Affairs had lost track of thousands of asylum seekers.
Zuma warned that the inability to trace individuals after their release could also pose security risks. He questioned what would happen if someone released from detention, whom he described as a mercenary, could not be traced and subsequently committed a crime.
The Johannesburg High Court’s inspection in loco is intended to give the judges first-hand insight into conditions at Lindela and the practical management of immigration detention before they decide whether detention beyond 120 days should be prohibited.
The court’s eventual ruling could have significant implications for how Home Affairs manages asylum seekers, undocumented foreign nationals and deportations, as well as the length of time individuals may lawfully be detained while their cases are being finalised.


