Health Minister Dr Aaron Motsoaledi has sought to set the record straight after suggesting that the Constitutional Court judges hearing the case on challenges to the NHI Act are benefiting from private healthcare.
This follows an International Nurses Day event in the Eastern Cape, where Motsoaledi reportedly cast doubt on the judges’ ability to rule fairly on the matter, saying: “They are beneficiaries of the same system that I am talking about, but they must preside over a judgement.”
The Department of Health released a statement on Saturday, clarifying the Minister’s sentiments through an apology.
“This reference was made by the Minister to demonstrate the systemic challenges caused by gross inequalities within the country’s two-tiered health system, characterised by a well-resourced, heavily state-subsidised private sector which caters for a privileged minority, while the majority are dependent on an under-resourced public sector,” the Department’s spokesperson, Foster Mohale, explained.
He added that the Minister has full confidence in the work of the judiciary.
“These comments should in no way be construed as second-guessing the judiciary’s ability to remain impartial when adjudicating challenges to the constitutionality of the NHI. The Minister wishes to state categorically that he has full confidence and trust in the fairness and integrity of the judiciary and its commitment to upholding the rights enshrined in the Constitution and the rule of law,” said Mohale.
He concluded by issuing an apology on behalf of Motsoaledi for any misunderstanding and unintended display of disrespect towards the judges.
The Department assured that the Minister would fully accept and respect the verdict of the Court in this matter.
The Court’s ruling on the matter remains critical and will shape the future of healthcare in the country.
President Cyril Ramaphosa had to pause the enactment of any provisions of the NHI Act due to pending challenges raised by stakeholders in the sector.
